Family with two kids

Local Insurance Agency

Licensed and specialized.

The Benninger Insurance Agency was founded in 1974 with the main philosophy of superior customer service. We remain committed to understanding and meeting the needs of our customers. We know that each customer’s situation is unique, so we look to find the most comprehensive personal insurance coverage at the most affordable price.

Our job is to ask questions, give you options, and help customize your policy to meet your personal insurance coverage needs. With years of experience, we have been providing homeowners insurance, auto insurance, and liability protection through the ERIE Insurance Group. This long-standing relationship has proven to be the backbone of our agency. It allows us to serve and give back to the community with the insurance coverage they need to live life to the fullest. We are based out of the Poconos region, and serve our clients throughout Monroe, Pike, Wayne, and Carbon Counties in Pennsylvania.