Quality Insurance

Licensed and specialized.

The Benninger Insurance Agency in Tannersville, PA was founded in 1974 by Bruce Benninger and later purchased by JMB, Inc. in 2008. We continue to emphasize our main philosophy of superior service to all customers.

Our licensed property and casualty independent insurance agents specialize in the sale of auto insurance, home insurance, commercial insurance and life insurance products in Northeastern Pennsylvania. As an independent insurance agency in the Poconos region, we can insure everything from a used car to a million-dollar business. With a commitment to our customers and community for over 40 years, our independent insurance agents and brokers take pride in providing you with the personal coverage you deserve. Customize your next insurance policy with A+ service through an A+ insurance agency, with insurance brokers who are here to better serve you. Our team of insurance agents serves businesses and individuals in Stroudsburg, Jim Thorpe, Hazelton, and Tobyhanna PA areas.

Coverage Policies

Automotive Insurance
Homeowners’ Insurance
Life Insurance
Liability Insurance
Commercial Insurance
On Site Services

Office Hours

Labor Day to Memorial Day
Monday – Friday: 9:00am – 5:00pm

Memorial Day to Labor Day
Monday – Friday: 9:00am – 5:00pm

Proudly Serving

Bartonsville, Sciota, Reeders, Mount Pocono, East Stroudsburg, Hawley, Saylorsburg, Long Pond, Bloomsburg, Lehighton, Palmerton, Boyertown, Stroudsburg, Tannersville, Snydersville, Tamaqua, Delaware Water Gap

Affiliate Carriers

Here at Benninger Insurance, we have built relationships with some of the best insurance companies in the country. By teaming up with them, we are able to offer substantially lower costs as an independent agency.

child & parent hands holding money jar


newsletter graphic