Personal, Commercial, Life

Insurance You Can Afford.

Benninger Insurance Agency has been providing commercial and personal insurance policies to our customers since 1974, serving the insurance needs of thousands of individuals, families, and businesses throughout Northeastern Pennsylvania.

Get Started Today

In Loving Memory of Ron Brosky

Personal Insurance

We know that each customer’s situation is unique, so we look to find the most comprehensive personal insurance coverage at the most affordable price.
Click To Learn More

Life Insurance

The number one question our customers ask us about life insurance is “How much do I really need?” Our team of professionals can help you with that and more!
Click To Learn More

Commercial Insurance

If you own a business, then you know that having the right commercial insurance coverage is just as important as getting customers through the door.
Click To Learn More
benninger sign

Who We Are

Our mission, values, and philosophy.

The Benninger Insurance Agency in Tannersville, PA was founded in 1974 by Bruce Benninger and later purchased by JMB, Inc. in 2008. We continue to emphasize our main philosophy of superior service to all customers. With a commitment to our customers and community for over 40 years, our independent insurance agents and brokers take pride in providing you with the personal coverage you deserve. Customize your next insurance policy with A+ service through an A+ insurance agency, with insurance brokers who are here to better serve you.

Independent Agency

We are an independent insurance agency, and are members of the Professional Insurance Agents Association. We represent and have access to a carefully selected group of financially sound, reputable insurance companies; therefore, we are able to offer you the best coverage at the most competitive prices.

Competitive Rates

At Benninger Insurance, we not only offer a convenient way to find the lowest insurance rates in the area, but we happily gather the lowest rates and help you choose the best one for you, your family, or your employees. Our skilled agents are extremely knowledgeable in all areas of insurance to provide you with an easier understanding of your policy options.

Available For You

Our office in Tannersville PA is always here to serve your insurance needs. Let our helpful team give you the best quality insurance service in the area. Our office is open Monday – Friday from 9am – 5pm and Saturday from 9am – 12pm. We also offer additional hours available by appointment only. Call today to schedule your appointment with Benninger Insurance.

Get A Quote

Work with one of these insurance companies.

File A Claim

Teaming up with some of the top insurance companies.

Here at Benninger Insurance, we have built relationships with some of the best insurance companies in the country. By teaming up with them, we are able to offer substantially lower costs as an independent agency. So if you’re looking to switch your insurance company, we have the best of both worlds – comprehensive coverage at a lower price. See for yourself the number of insurance providers we work with to bring you the absolute best in insurance coverage.

Make A Payment.

Pay Through Erie Insurance