Welcome

Auto Insurance - Home Insurance - Life Insurance and Business Insurance, sold by local agents with your best interests in mind. Benninger Insurance Agency has been providing commercial and personal lines of insurance to our customers since 1974 serving the insurance needs of thousands of individuals, families, and businesses throughout Northeast, Pennsylvania.

We are an independent insurance agency, and are members of the Professional Insurance Agents Association. We represent and have access to a carefully selected group of financially sound, reputable insurance companies; therefore, we are able to offer you the best coverage at the most competitive prices. Our Tannersville office can serve your insurance needs today and forever.

Get A Quote

Use these links to compare the cost of coverage available through two of our most competitive auto insurance carriers, ERIE Insurance Group and Progressive Insurance.  Your information will be forwarded to our agency and we will contact you upon our next available business day.